|
Foot & Mouth Disease
Archive - November 2001
CAPS looks at the effect the foot and mouth crisis had on zoos
and circuses.
Foot and mouth is a highly infectious viral disease. Seven different
types have been identified and it is extremely resilient. The virus
can survive for some time outside its hosts, be carried on their
breath and so on. Consequently, when it arrives it is capable of
spreading very quickly.
However, although it is a remarkable virus, the impact of the disease
is primarily economic. Infected livestock becomes less productive,
has lower milk yields and puts on less weight. In many countries,
foot and mouth disease (FMD) is endemic and as a result they are
unable to export livestock to disease-free countries. It was this,
coupled with long term reduced productivity, that the government
was purporting to avoid as it began to slaughter and burn tens of
thousands of animals this year.
Many zoo and circus animals can contract or carry the disease.
Thus, with the entire reason for the government's brutal culling
campaign being to restore Britain's disease free status, it is vital
that FMD does not infect these animals.
 |
 |
 |
 |
|
|
| ...the entrance to Blackpool Zoo. |
|
| A vehicle goes through the children's zoo. |
|
| A lemur within touching distance. |
|
The potential for zoo animals to harbour the virus was highlighted
last year, by a horrific journey endured by 22 giraffes and 3 white
rhinos. The animals had been taken from the wild at a game reserve
in South Africa and sold to zoos in Madrid, Alicante and Santander
(at £1,200 per giraffe and £75,000 per rhino). They
sailed up Africa's west coast to Valencia, but were refused entry
to Spain, because they had previously driven through KwaZulu Natal
where there was an FMD outbreak. So, they went to Malta to be transferred
to another boat, sailed through the Mediterranean and Suez Canal,
down the east coast of Africa, to be unloaded for a 500 mile road
trip back to the reserve they began life at. Forty days at sea and
the collapse of a £251,400 deal.
So, as the UK's FMD epidemic unfolded in February, Government officials
began discussions with zoo authorities about restrictions.
The virus can be carried on clothing, hair, footwear and even in
the nasal passages of visitors. Even when the zoos were closed,
there was still a risk. The virus can be windborne, carried in by
staff, or by wild birds and mammals. Animals including antelope,
elephants, tapir, giraffe, llama are all susceptible. The potential
for these attractions, with their throughput of visitors from all
over the country to contract the virus is high.
Ministry of Agriculture guidelines for zoos include: 'Contact between
visitors and animals could occur if animals have access to public
paths, e.g. animals used to give rides, displays or shows, crossing
paths between enclosures. Animals in "kids corners" etc
where there is intimate contact. Stop all contact between public
and stock. Stop rides, shows, displays or any other events involving
direct contact with animals.'
Alton Towers took no chances, simply killing every animal in its
'petting zoo', so that it could carry on business as usual.
For some it appeared to be business as usual. CAPS heard from a
visitor to Paradise Park, Broxbourne zoo, who claimed to
have seen a young camel arrive there in a circus trailer bearing
the name 'The Great British Circus'. The camel was swapped for a
larger male camel. A member of the Federation of Zoos apparently
exchanging a camel with a travelling circus!
Initially, several zoos and safari parks appeared to be staying
closed. Although, whilst Whipsnade Animal Park was closed
to the public because of FMD the Aldenham Harriers held their hunt
ball there with about 400 people attending!
But, as the time approached when zoos would actually be turning
away trade, resolve appeared to dissolve. So CAPS made one day visits
to some zoos to see what precautions were being taken.
 |
 |
 |
 |
| The elephant enclosure is open... |
|
| ...despite instructions from MAFF. |
|
|
| ...putting money before lives? |
|
|
Blackpool Zoo
At the gate, there were disinfectant mats, visitors were
handed information and questioned concerning FMD. Asked. 'Have
you been within 10km of an infected area?' our supporter responded
'Not that I know of but I don't know where the infected areas
are'. They were asked if they had any food and informed that
sealed food, in this instance biscuits and crisps, was acceptable,
and that the main concerns were sandwiches and dairy products.
The elephant performances were still on, and visitors were
even allowed into the elephant house. Most surprisingly, the
lemur walkway was open where people were able to get close
to the lemurs and visitors were allowed to walk through enclosures
such as the aviary. The children's zoo was closed but zoo
vehicles and staff entered it from the rest of the zoo without
extra precautions, such as disinfectant mats.
Chester Zoo
Cars entering the car park had to go over a disinfectant mat
and visitors then had to walk over another. Staff also wiped
the shoes of the children in pushchairs. No questions were
asked about being near animals or infected areas, no advice
was given about FMD.
Although visitors were not allowed right up to the guanacos
they could still get quite close. Also, extra stand-off barriers
had been added in some areas to stop people touching some
of the animals. The Elephant house was closed but it was still
possible to get quite close to the elephants outside. Access
to the rhino house was also closed.
Knowsley Safari
Cars had to drive across disinfectant mats, and passengers
had to get out and walk on another. Visitors were not questioned
if they had been in contact with animals or in an FMD area,
although they were given a slip of paper which said amongst
other things 'do not feed or try to touch any animal'. We
were concerned that people might not read this before touring
the park.
There were additional disinfectant mats outside the zoo shop,
café, and toilets and these appeared to be 'topped-up'
during the day.
The children's zoo and giraffe house were closed, and visitors
were not allowed out of cars near the elephant house. However,
all other animals, including deer and cattle, were on show
as usual - people were even touching the deer. No signs around
the park gave FMD warnings and staff did not stop people feeding
animals.
|
|
Dudley Zoo
In early May, CAPS phoned to check that the zoo was open and
heard a recorded message which included FMD warnings/precautions.
At the entrance were small signs and others around the zoo,
but these could easily be missed. No mention of FMD when paying
to enter, nor queries regarding food. There was however a
disinfectant foot mat at both the entry and exit.
Following her talk at the elephant enclosure, the keeper
spoke about FMD and asked people to eat in designated areas,
not to take food out of the zoo, and to watch out and report
anyone feeding animals. But no announcements of this nature
were being made over the public address system on the day
we visited.
All animals appeared to be out on display, so, although the
elephant and giraffe houses were closed, they could nonetheless
get quite close to the public. Some other additional precautions
had been taken, for example temporary stand-off barriers around
the lynx and Geoffroys cats.
Southport Zoo
At the entrance, there were no disinfectant mats and no questions
asked!
The Children's zoo was closed and rope was being being used
apparently to prevent visitors getting too close to llamas
But all other animals were on display as usual.
A pot bellied pig was being stroked by children. A small
sign on the enclosure asked people not to feed or touch but
this was amongst other signs and not prominent.
Another sign told visitors, 'Due to the Foot and Mouth epidemic
we would ask you to refrain from touching or feeding any of
our animals and respect all barriers and cordoned off areas.'
But this appeared to have little impact. Several people had
small white bags possibly containing nuts/seeds and were throwing
these into various enclosures. A couple of visitors were feeding
biscuits to the llamas, and sweets and lollipops to the chimps
and gibbons. No one attempted to stop them even though they
drew a crowd around the Lar gibbon enclosure.
|
FMD meant that there were hardly any animal circuses on the
road in the UK this summer.
Circus King toured without any animals at all. Hopefully
if they have had a hassle free and productive year, they may think
twice about using animals in future.
The Great British Circus had said that they wished to use
big cats and reindeer in their circus this year, but because of
the outbreak they reduced the number of animals they used. Although
a young leopard was used for media photo shoots in Essex.
Bobby Roberts began his tour without his elephants, but
included them in his performances near Rhyl in August.
FMD has not gone away, and may even get worse during the winter.
Questions are being asked in the livestock industry about the husbandry
and unnecessary movement of animals. But what of those in entertainment:
The huge number of zoo animal collections and the vast diversity
of species involved; and the circus menageries that by their very
nature move location every week?
HOW YOU CAN HELP
 |
Don't visit zoos or circuses - your money keeps
them in business. |
 |
Become a CAPS
supporter - you can help to make
a difference. |
|